Who is Harassing Whom - Dr. Richard Warshak

At some point in nearly every case of a child’s severe estrangement from a parent, the child and the parent with whom she is aligned label the other parent’s attempts to reach out to the child as “harassment.” The child rebuffs phone calls, texts, emails, greeting cards, invitations, even gifts. Not only does the child deflect efforts to connect. The efforts, themselves, are cast as further reasons for the child’s rejection.

Your ex might ask, “Why would my child want to have anything to do with you when all you do is harass her?” (Note that the child is no longer considered “our” child.)
What is that you do that constitutes harassment? Do you harp on your child’s faults? Do you pick on your child’s weaknesses? Do you persistently tell your child what to do, never allowing her a moment of peace? Do you constantly scream at your child?
Or is your sole transgression your unwillingness to accept a break in your relationship with your child—your refusal to accept that your child will no longer be able to show love to you and receive love from you?
Rejected parents face a catch-22 bind. By trying to relate to their children, they prove that they are unworthy of a relationship. By trying to show love to their children, they prove that they do not love them. The alternative is to relinquish efforts to establish contact, in which case parents are accused of not caring about their children.
I have seen many cases in which a child and the aligned parent demanded that the rejected parent simply wait patiently for when the child is “ready” to reach out. I have yet to see a case in which the child became “ready” within a reasonable period of time and responded to a rejected parent’s withdrawal by renewing contact. Would we ask a parent to be patient with a sick child’s avoidance of a doctor, and wait until the child is “ready” to be treated? Or wait until a truant child decides that she is “ready” to attend school?
And since when do children criticize their parents using legal jargon? Teenagers certainly complain about their parents’ behavior. “Stop bugging me,” they cry. “Get off my case.” “Leave me alone.” “You’re annoying me.” Typical teen belligerence. But children rarely charge their parents with “harassment” unless the children get caught in the maelstrom of a parent’s alienating behavior. When a child’s complaint echoes the language of the alienating parent’s legal motions, we have to wonder how the child learned to use the word “harassment” to describe a loving parent’s efforts to heal a damaged relationship.
When a child is irrationally alienated from the parent, often there IS plenty of harassment in the relationship. But it is not the parent harassing the child. It’s the other way around. The child harps on the rejected parent’s alleged faults and acts in ways that make the parent feel miserable. The child attempts to control the parent, makes abusive remarks and threats, and destroys property.
When parents face the charge of harassing their children, we must ask: “Who is harassing whom?”

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Parental Alienation: It can happen at any age

Don't believe what they say: that Parental Alienation cannot happen to older children, that it's just an oxymoron. Parental Alienation is the act of one parent deliberately undermining the relationship between the children and the other parent to the point of creating a hostile relationship and thus alienation of the children from the other parent. Another way to look at this is alienation of affection, which is one of the basic human needs discussed at length by Maslow in his Hierarchy of Needs. It is a serious form of psychological abuse, and it is very dangerous because it occurs internally and, thus, is harder to treat. Unlike physical abuse where the scars and wounds are on the outside, Parental Alienation Syndrome (PAS) is so deep inside that unlocking the key to it takes years of treatment and unconditional love. Though PAS is primarily seen in high-conflict divorces, it also occurs in intact families. And though it usually begins in early childhood, this is not alw...
Read more

Amy Baker’s Study on Adult Children of PAS

When Ties to a Parent Are Cut by the Other Article in the NY Times - Sept. 2007 THIS is a nice moment in Joe Rabiega’s life. At 31, he has a good job as a research coordinator for the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill. He is happily married and feels blessed that his wife of five years, Tiffany, is pregnant with their first child. His hope is to give that child a happier upbringing than the one he had. Mr. Rabiega’s parents divorced when he was 8, and though they were supposed to share custody, he said, his father, a truck driver with a drinking problem, did everything possible to turn him against his mother and eventually kept him from seeing her. “He bullied my mother into giving up custody,” Mr. Rabiega said. When he was still allowed to visit his mother, he’d have to stay by the phone to take a call from his father at 4 every afternoon and 8 each evening. He said his father trained him to spy on his mother’s socializing and spending habits. “His ability to manipulate he...
Read more

Terrorist in the Home

Establishing Fear, Anguish, and Apprehension in the ChildrenBy Joan T. KlothLife Coach/CounselorNovember 11,2007 What do you call it when a parent or person instills such fear and hatred in a child that he/she is afraid to love his/her other parent? What do you call it when a parent uses condescending words and actions to describe the other parent to the point of creating fear of that targeted parent? What do you call it when a parent threatens to not love a child if the child shows any love, compassion or feelings for the other parent? I call it Parental Alienation or Hostile Aggressive Parenting, but someone might call this Terrorism.Terrorism: the word strikes fear in most people's hearts. But what is the actual definition of Terrorism? According to Encarta World English Dictionary, it is: ter·ror·ism nviolence or the threat of violence, especially bombing, kidnapping, and assassination, carried out for political purposes. The synonyms for Terrorism are not better: Violence, int...
Read more